Berlin, 21.08.2015

Western Balkans Conference in Vienna: Gloomy Prospects for EU Accession Candidates

Dušan Reljić
Dušan Reljić

The economic situation in the Western Balkans is disastrous, EU accession perspectives barely credible. Rather than yet more empty words, the Western Balkans conference at the end of August should initiate investment programmes, says Dušan Reljić.

The assertion of Western Balkans governments that their countries have a perspective of joining the European Union – backed by the Brussels bureaucracy and politicians from EU member states – is sounding increasingly hollow. Similar threadbare assertions will likely be heard at the second Western Balkans conference on 27 August in Vienna. After three decades of war and strife, the accession perspective has become a political tranquilliser for this part of Southeastern Europe. But its credibility has largely evaporated, and the poorest of the poor have abandoned hopes of improvement and ever achieving a life with dignity: During the past year tens of thousands of Roma and Albanians have left their homes to seek a future in Germany and elsewhere in Western Europe.

Economic Stagnation and Political Turmoil

The first Conference on the Western Balkans, instigated by the German government, was held one year ago in Berlin. Political and business leaders from the region, the European Union and the EU member states came together with the primary objective of fostering economic cooperation between the Western Balkan states and with the European Union. This mechanism, the initiators believed, would speed EU membership, stem uncontrolled emigration, and curtail interference by external powers such as Russia, the Islamist regimes or Turkey, which the West does not want. But the statistics tell a different story. Since the outbreak of the economic and financial crisis in the European Union seven years ago, economic growth in the Southeastern European accession candidates has come to a standstill or fallen, while political turmoil has worsened. The pronouncements of the 2014 Western Balkans conference have done little to change that.

Apparently migrants assess the socio-economic circumstances more realistically than the governments of the Western Balkans and many of their foreign advisers. In 2014 the GDP of the Western Balkan states (including Croatia) was still 10 percent below the level of 1989, when the break-up of Yugoslavia began. According to the Economist Intelligence Unit per capita income is just 27 percent of the EU15 average and about half of the level of the countries that joined the Union between 2004 and 2007. One quarter of the adult population and 50 percent of young people are unemployed, investment is sparse, demand for products and services from Germany and Italy – the two most important trading partners – is sluggish, state debt is spiralling along with migration, and extreme poverty is proliferating, especially in Kosovo.

Economic atrophy leads to emigration of better-educated young people and thinning of the social base for liberal and progressive political options. Populists of all colours – some of whom bear personal responsibility for nationalist incitement during the Wars of Yugoslav Secession of 1991–2001 – have long since regained the upper hand. Although they all pay lip service to future EU membership, the consequences of their policies are devastating. Worst of all, they are incapable of securing greater employment and a fairer distribution of income. While this is partly due to the repercussions of the economic crisis in the EU, the refusal of current leaders to share power makes matters worse. They shy from reforms that would relieve business and society of state paternalism and make leaders politically accountable. And thus the standard of living continues to fall, political institutions deteriorate, political power concentrates uncontrolled in the hands of individuals, ethnic chauvinism grows apace, and freedom of speech and the press suffer.

No Impact of Political Reforms without Economic Growth

Better governance and reforms of political and economic institutions – as demanded by EU leaders, usually with little reference to the economic weakness of the countries concerned – will not on their own alleviate the misery. How, for example, can the labour market be further liberalised in the face of such a low employment rate? Can the state become even »slimmer« without condemning further tens of thousands to unemployment? Without economic growth, political reforms will remain without impact. It is plain that the Western Balkan states are incapable of generating growth on their own. If they are indeed to join the EU in the medium term, employment-generating investment, initiated and backed by the EU and its member states, will be crucial. The candidate countries must also be granted greater access to the EU labour market, in order to tackle uncontrolled emigration. Further, the Western Balkan states should be included fully in as many EU policy areas as possible, such as energy, transport, environment, climate and agriculture. Otherwise ongoing economic and social backsliding will accelerate the already glaring erosion of democracy and collapse of stability in Southeastern Europe.

A German Version of this »Point of View« has been translated into English by Meredith Dale.

The text has also been published by EurActiv.com.

Further Reading

Dušan Reljić

Does the EU want to bring Russia and Turkey into the Western Balkans?

As there are no signs that the EU economy will revitalize soon and lift with it the Western Balkans, the region is looking for new business partners.

in: EurActive, 12.12.2014, (online)
Andrea Despot, Dušan Reljić, Günter Seufert

Ten Years of Solitude

Turkey and the Western Balkans Require Practical Integration Measures to Bridge the Hiatus in the European Union Enlargement Process

SWP Comments 2012/C 16, May 2012, 8 Pages
 

SWP Comments

Christian Opitz, Tobias Etzold
Seeking Renewed Relevance

Institutions of Nordic Cooperation in the Reform Process


Amal Jamal
The Rise of “Bad Civil Society” in Israel

Nationalist Civil Society Organizations and the Politics of Delegitimization


SWP Research Papers

Marianne Beisheim, Anne Ellersiek
Partnerships for the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development

Transformative, Inclusive and Accountable?


Kirsten Westphal, Aurélie Bros, Tatiana Mitrova
German-Russian Gas Relations

A Special Relationship in Troubled Waters